This recipe was shared by our friend Ann-Michelle, who brought it to us for dessert one Friday night. It’s incredibly delicious, super easy to make, and unhealthy (consider yourself warned). It makes three pies which is lucky because you may eat one while waiting to serve the others. Freezes well but rewarm before serving.
2 Duncan Heinz brownie mixes, the 9×13 size (alternatively you may make homemade brownies but it is really not necessary)
24 cookies worth of chocolate chip cookie dough (Kineret works well)
3 graham cracker pie crusts
Top with pareve whipping cream or pareve vanilla ice cream
Preheat the oven to 350 degrees.
Make brownies following the “cakey” version on the box. Divide batter between the three pie crusts. Crumble the cookies on top (8 cookies per pie). Bake 30-45 min. It is going to be VERY VERY wet in the middle when you check it with a toothpick, so, after 30 min, check the part of the pie closer to the crust with a toothpick. It should still be VERY wet but not totally batter. This is better undercooked than overbaked. Depending on the oven calibration, cooking time is 30 -43 minutes. Delicious served warm with whipped pareve cream or pareve vanilla ice cream.